Olivia - Rodrigo - Traitor

Produced by Dan Nigro, the track has an almost "old country" feel that Olivia was obsessed with at the time, blending soft-folk and indie pop elements with a cinematic, choir-like opening. "Guess You Didn't Cheat, But You're Still a Traitor"

Surprisingly, one of the most successful tracks on the album wasn't meticulously over-engineered. Olivia has shared that she wrote the hook while hiking with her mother in Salt Lake City. She later finished the entire song in just on her bedroom floor, rushing to finish so she could go out with a friend. Olivia Rodrigo - Traitor

Despite not being released as a lead single, "traitor" took on a life of its own. It debuted at , making Olivia the first artist in history to have three songs in the top 10 simultaneously for consecutive weeks. Produced by Dan Nigro, the track has an

The genius of the song lies in its central thesis: emotional betrayal can hurt just as much as physical infidelity. The lyrics detail a partner who moves on just two weeks after a breakup—with the very person they told you not to worry about. Key themes explored in the track include: She later finished the entire song in just

Playing "dumb" while knowing deep down that something was wrong.

The song's enduring popularity was evident years later; by August 2025, it was still pulling in over on Spotify.