The Highlander is the clear winner for daily commuting and road trips.

The Highlander seats up to eight passengers with a more usable third row. The 4Runner typically seats five, though a smaller optional third row can expand capacity to seven.

Known for being "thirsty," older V6 models average only 16–19 MPG . Even newer 2025 hybrid models only reach about 23 MPG. 3. Interior Space & Family Features

While the 4Runner has a slightly higher maximum cargo volume (up to 89.7 cu. ft. with seats folded), the Highlander offers more space when the third row is actually in use (16.0 cu. ft. vs. 9.0 cu. ft.). 4. Reliability & Maintenance

Annual maintenance is similar, though the Highlander is slightly cheaper at an average of $489/year compared to the 4Runner’s $514/year .

You frequently go off-roading, need to tow up to 6,000 lbs (on newer models), or want a durable "tank-like" vehicle with high resale value.

Standard gas models achieve roughly 21–29 MPG, while the Highlander Hybrid delivers an impressive 35–36 MPG .

The 4Runner traditionally holds its value better over five years, often retaining thousands more in equity than the Highlander . Technical Specifications Comparison Toyota 4Runner (2024/2025) Toyota Highlander (2025) Platform Body-on-Frame (Truck-based) Unibody (Car-based) Max Towing 5,000 – 6,000 lbs Ground Clearance 9.6 – 10.1 inches 8.0 inches Seating 5 (7 optional) Hybrid Option Yes (2025+ Models) Yes ( Highlander Hybrid ) Best MPG ~23 MPG (Hybrid) ~36 MPG (Hybrid) Toyota Highlander Vs. Toyota 4Runner: Specs, Size & More